Colchester Investment Counsel LLC logo

Colchester Investment Counsel LLC

Updated today

Client AUM

$128,851,449

Clients

58

Advisors

2

of 3 employees

About

Colchester Investment Counsel LLC provides discretionary investment management and standalone financial planning to individuals, families, small businesses, and charitable organizations. The firm manages approximately $128.8 million across roughly 58 client relationships and typically constructs portfolios using individual equities, investment‑grade fixed income, exchange‑traded funds, and no‑load or closed‑end mutual funds.

Colchester’s approach combines fundamental and technical analysis with an emphasis on asset allocation and long‑term holdings, seeking attractive long‑term returns while aiming to limit portfolio risk. The firm conducts ongoing monitoring with weekly reviews and periodic in‑depth client meetings, uses Schwab Institutional for custody and execution, and employs the Pontera platform to facilitate discretionary management of held‑away defined‑contribution accounts.

Noteworthy features include a small team with credentialed investment professionals (CFA and CFP designations) and the firm’s occasional use of borrowing techniques in separately managed accounts—for example, engaging in short sales that require borrowing securities to reduce equity exposure—a practice that is uncommon among similar supported firms. Colchester generally requires a $1 million minimum (waivable), provides quarterly reporting and client letters, and typically leaves proxy voting to clients unless expressly requested to vote.

Client services

Financial planning Portfolio management

Expertise

General retirement planning Social Security optimization General tax planning Cash flow / budgeting

Want help finding the right advisor?

Answer a few questions to see advisors matched to you.

Fee options

Percentage

$0 - $1,000,000: 1.00% per annum $1,000,000 - $3,000,000: 0.875% per annum $3,000,000+: Negotiable

Project-based

Fees for financial planning services are negotiable and depend on the complexity of the plan.

Other

Account minimum: $1,000,000

Main office

440 Main Street, Suite R

Ridgefield CT 06877

Advisors at this office

2

Most active in

Connecticut · Florida · New York

Disclosures

Exclamation point means they have disclosures of this type. Check mark means no disclosures of this type were found.

Business activities & affiliations

Advisors at this firm

user avatar

Evan K

CFP®, Series 65

Ridgefield, CT

Colchester Investment Counsel LLC

Evan Kenagy is a CFP® with eight years of industry experience, currently serving at Colchester Investment Counsel LLC since 2018. His prior experience includes roles at Silver Spring Country Club, The Gym, and Jericho Partnership. Colchester Investment Counsel LLC provides discretionary investment management and financial planning to individuals, families, small businesses, and charitable organizations. The firm employs a combination of fundamental and technical analysis with a focus on asset allocation and long-term holdings, managing approximately $128.8 million across diverse client portfolios.

General retirement planning Social Security optimization General tax planning Cash flow / budgeting
user avatar

Neil K

CFA®

Ridgefield, CT

Colchester Investment Counsel LLC

Neil Kenagy is a CFA® charterholder with 23 years of experience in the financial industry. He has been with Colchester Investment Counsel LLC since 2000. Colchester Investment Counsel provides discretionary investment management and standalone financial planning services to individuals, families, small businesses, and charitable organizations. The firm employs a long-term, relatively conservative investment approach that combines fundamental and technical analysis, focusing on dividend-oriented equities and investment-grade bonds, while tailoring asset allocation to clients’ goals and risk tolerance.

General retirement planning Social Security optimization General tax planning Cash flow / budgeting
View complete list of advisors at this firm
Warmer team member

Not sure where to start?

We'll help you think it through—whether you ultimately need an advisor or not. Warmer helps you compare advisors clearly, so you can choose with confidence.

Find your advisor

For advisor listings, we rely on sources including public filings and data provided by advisors, and we cannot guarantee that all information is current or accurate. Advisors are independent and may not have reviewed or updated this information. Please review an advisor's Form ADV and do your own diligence before deciding whether to work with them.

Advisor matching and referrals are provided by FinanceHQ LLC ("FHQ"), a wholly-owned subsidiary of Warmer and an SEC-registered investment adviser. We may be compensated by participating advisors. You pay no fee to use our matching service, and advisor fees are not increased because of a referral. We do not supervise advisors, manage or hold assets, guarantee performance, or provide advice about specific investments.

By using our service, you agree to the Warmer Terms of Service and FHQ Advisory Agreement, and acknowledge Warmer's Privacy Policy. Please review FHQ's ADV Part 2A and Form CRS. Logos provided by Logo.dev

© 2026 Warmer Holdings Inc. ("Warmer")