Stewardship Advisors, LLC logo

Stewardship Advisors, LLC

Updated today

Client assets under management

$510,567,330

Clients

674

22% high-net-worth

Advisors

9

of 15 employees

Firm type

Team

5-30 advisors or >$500M in AUM

Clients per advisor

75

High

Average account size

$757,518

About

Stewardship Advisors, LLC serves individuals (including high‑net‑worth clients), businesses, charitable organizations, and retirement plan sponsors by offering financial planning, investment consultation, and portfolio management services that can be implemented directly or through institutional third‑party managers. The firm’s team of nine advisors manages roughly $545 million in client assets across about 674 client relationships and also provides periodic educational workshops on personal finance and investing.

The firm’s investment approach emphasizes strategic asset allocation implemented primarily with ETFs and mutual funds, employing a blend of fundamental and technical analysis and managing accounts on both discretionary and nondiscretionary bases. Stewardship prepares written investment guidelines, conducts ongoing monitoring and periodic rebalancing, and offers a values‑based ESG portfolio that uses Morningstar screening as part of its due diligence and portfolio design.

Distinctive features include complimentary public workshops—a relatively uncommon service among peer team firms—and a prior role as a wrap fee program sponsor, from which it is now moving away and no longer accepting new wrap participants. The firm routinely recommends specific custodians (including Schwab, Trade‑PMR, Betterment Securities and SEI), discloses that it may receive custodial services and portions of fees when third‑party managers are employed, and states it conducts reviews and due diligence around those arrangements.

Client services

Financial planning Portfolio management Pension consulting Selection of other advisers Newsletters or periodicals Educational seminars or workshops

Expertise

Cash flow / budgeting College savings (529s, UTMA, etc.) General retirement planning Tax strategies for small businesses Charitable giving & philanthropy

Occupation focus

Founder/Business Owner Retired

Want help finding the right advisor?

Answer a few questions to see advisors matched to you.

Fee options

Percentage

$0 - $249,999: 1.50% annually $250,000 - $499,999: 1.25% annually $500,000 - $999,999: 1.00% annually $1,000,000 - $1,499,999: 0.90% annually $1,500,000 - $1,999,999: 0.80% annually $2,000,000 - $2,999,999: 0.70% annually $3,000,000 - $4,999,999: 0.60% annually $5,000,000 - $7,499,999: 0.50% annually $7,500,000 - $9,999,999: 0.45% annually $10,000,000 - Above: Negotiable

Subscriptions

Annual consultation arrangement fees from $100 to $1,000 per month, paid monthly or quarterly

Other

Account minimum: $25,000 Fee-only: Fixed fees from $1,000 to $10,000 for project-based financial planning; annual consultation fees from $100 to $1,000 per month

Main office location

Stewardship Advisors, LLC

321 W. Main Street

Mount Joy PA 17552, United States

Number of offices

1

Most active in

Florida · Pennsylvania · Texas

Disclosures

Exclamation point means they have disclosures of this type. Check mark means no disclosures of this type were found.

Business activities & affiliations

Advisors at this firm

user avatar

Leanne F

Series 66

Mount Joy, PA

Stewardship Advisors, LLC

Leanne Fee is a Series 66 credentialed financial advisor at Stewardship Advisors, LLC with 21 years of industry experience. She has previously worked at Ameriprise Financial Services, Inc. and Private Client Services. In addition to her advisory role, Leanne serves as a Notary Public in Mount Joy, PA. Stewardship Advisors, LLC is a team of nine advisors managing approximately $545 million in assets, serving individuals, businesses, charitable organizations, and retirement plan sponsors. The firm offers financial planning, investment consultation, and portfolio management services, emphasizing strategic asset allocation primarily through ETFs and mutual funds, and provides complimentary public workshops on personal finance and investing.

Cash flow / budgeting College savings (529s, UTMA, etc.) General retirement planning Tax strategies for small businesses Charitable giving & philanthropy Founder/Business Owner Retired
user avatar

Mark B

CFP®, Series 63, Series 65

Mount Joy, PA

Stewardship Advisors, LLC

Mark Brinser is a CFP® with 18 years of experience in the financial industry. He has worked at Stewardship Advisors, LLC since 2011 and previously at Private Client Services, LLC, as well as Cambridge Investment Research, Inc. Brinser also serves as an independent insurance agent for various companies and is involved as a partner in a real estate venture, Freedom Offices. Stewardship Advisors, LLC serves individuals, businesses, charitable organizations, and retirement plan sponsors by providing financial planning, investment consultation, and portfolio management. The firm employs a strategic asset allocation approach using ETFs and mutual funds, offers a values-based ESG portfolio, and conducts public financial education workshops.

Cash flow / budgeting College savings (529s, UTMA, etc.) General retirement planning Tax strategies for small businesses Charitable giving & philanthropy Founder/Business Owner Retired
user avatar

John S

Series 63, Series 65

Mount Joy, PA

Stewardship Advisors, LLC

John Simkins is a financial advisor at Stewardship Advisors, LLC with 27 years of industry experience. He holds Series 63 and Series 65 licenses and has worked at Stewardship Advisors since 2011, with prior experience at Cambridge Investment Research, Inc. Outside of his advisory role, he teaches Sunday school and serves on the finance committee at Elizabethtown Mennonite Church, as well as serving as a board member for No Longer Alone Ministries. Stewardship Advisors, LLC serves individuals, businesses, charitable organizations, and retirement plan sponsors by providing financial planning, investment consultation, and portfolio management services. The firm employs a team-based approach with nine advisors managing approximately $545 million in client assets, emphasizing strategic asset allocation through ETFs and mutual funds, and offering values-based ESG portfolios alongside educational workshops on personal finance and investing.

Cash flow / budgeting College savings (529s, UTMA, etc.) General retirement planning Tax strategies for small businesses Charitable giving & philanthropy Founder/Business Owner Retired
user avatar

Logan K

CFP®, Series 63

Mount Joy, PA

Stewardship Advisors, LLC

Logan Kready is a CFP® certificant with two years of industry experience, currently serving as a financial advisor at Stewardship Advisors, LLC since 2020. His prior roles include positions at PFM Asset Management LLC and BNY Mellon. Outside of his advisory duties, he is a partner and shareholder in 5K Enterprises LLC. Stewardship Advisors, LLC serves individuals, businesses, charitable organizations, and retirement plan sponsors by providing financial planning, investment consultation, and portfolio management. The firm employs a strategic asset allocation approach primarily using ETFs and mutual funds, offers a values-based ESG portfolio, and conducts educational workshops on personal finance and investing.

Cash flow / budgeting College savings (529s, UTMA, etc.) General retirement planning Tax strategies for small businesses Charitable giving & philanthropy Founder/Business Owner Retired
user avatar

Zachary D

Series 66

Mount Joy, PA

Stewardship Advisors, LLC

Zachary Drescher is a financial advisor at Stewardship Advisors, LLC with 10 years of industry experience. He holds a Series 66 designation and previously worked at Private Client Services LLC and Cambridge Investment Research, Inc. Zachary has been with Stewardship Advisors since 2015. Stewardship Advisors, LLC serves individuals, businesses, charitable organizations, and retirement plan sponsors by providing financial planning, investment consultation, and portfolio management services. The firm employs a strategic asset allocation approach using ETFs and mutual funds, offers values-based ESG portfolios, and provides complimentary public workshops on personal finance and investing.

Cash flow / budgeting College savings (529s, UTMA, etc.) General retirement planning Tax strategies for small businesses Charitable giving & philanthropy Founder/Business Owner Retired
user avatar

Thomas T

CFP®, Series 63, Series 65

Mount Joy, PA

Stewardship Advisors, LLC

Thomas Talbott is a CFP® professional with 24 years of industry experience, currently serving at Stewardship Advisors, LLC since 2014. Prior to that, he was with Cambridge Investment Research Advisors from 2014 to 2016. He is a board member of ServingLeaders Ministries, a nonprofit organization, where he contributes approximately 30 hours annually. Stewardship Advisors, LLC is a nine-advisor team that provides financial planning, investment consultation, and portfolio management services to individuals, businesses, charitable organizations, and retirement plan sponsors. The firm emphasizes strategic asset allocation using ETFs and mutual funds, with a values-based ESG portfolio option and offers complimentary public workshops on personal finance and investing.

Cash flow / budgeting College savings (529s, UTMA, etc.) General retirement planning Tax strategies for small businesses Charitable giving & philanthropy Founder/Business Owner Retired
user avatar

Benjamin W

CFP®

Mount Joy, PA

Stewardship Advisors, LLC

Benjamin Writer is a CFP® professional with Stewardship Advisors, LLC in Mount Joy, PA. He has been with the firm since 2021 and previously operated a lawn care business for seven years. Stewardship Advisors, LLC is a team of nine advisors managing approximately $545 million in assets for individuals, businesses, charitable organizations, and retirement plan sponsors. The firm focuses on strategic asset allocation using ETFs and mutual funds, combining fundamental and technical analysis, and offers services including financial planning, investment consultation, and portfolio management.

Cash flow / budgeting College savings (529s, UTMA, etc.) General retirement planning Tax strategies for small businesses Charitable giving & philanthropy Founder/Business Owner Retired
user avatar

Jay K

Series 63, Series 65

Mount Joy, PA

Stewardship Advisors, LLC

Jay Kready is a financial advisor at Stewardship Advisors, LLC with 23 years of industry experience. His career includes roles at Everence Trust Company, ProEquities, Everence Financial Advisors, and Concourse Financial Group Securities, Inc. Outside of advising, he is involved in several family and partnership real estate ventures focusing on investment properties. Stewardship Advisors, LLC serves individuals, businesses, charitable organizations, and retirement plan sponsors with financial planning, investment consultation, and portfolio management. The firm manages approximately $545 million in client assets, emphasizing strategic asset allocation using ETFs and mutual funds along with a values-based ESG portfolio option, and offers complimentary public workshops on personal finance and investing.

Cash flow / budgeting College savings (529s, UTMA, etc.) General retirement planning Tax strategies for small businesses Charitable giving & philanthropy Founder/Business Owner Retired
user avatar

Wilbur S

CFP®, ChFC®, Series 63, Series 65

Mount Joy, PA

Stewardship Advisors, LLC

Wilbur Shertzer is a CFP® and ChFC® with 39 years of industry experience. He is a financial advisor at Stewardship Advisors, LLC, where he has worked since 2011. Prior to this, he was with Cambridge Investment Research, Inc. and Cambridge Investment Research Advisors, Inc. from 2011 to 2016. Outside of his advisory role, Shertzer serves as treasurer for Black Rock Retreat, a camp and retreat center. Stewardship Advisors, LLC serves individuals, businesses, charitable organizations, and retirement plan sponsors by providing financial planning, investment consultation, and portfolio management services. The firm emphasizes strategic asset allocation using ETFs and mutual funds, blending fundamental and technical analysis, and offers a values-based ESG portfolio.

Cash flow / budgeting College savings (529s, UTMA, etc.) General retirement planning Tax strategies for small businesses Charitable giving & philanthropy Founder/Business Owner Retired
Warmer team member

Not sure where to start?

We'll help you think it through — whether you ultimately need an advisor or not.

Warmer helps you compare advisors clearly — so you can choose with confidence.

Find your advisor
Discover

Compare top advisor firms by metric, firm size, and location.

Warmer provides personalized recommendations and introductions to independent fiduciary advisors. We do not supervise advisors, manage or hold assets, guarantee performance, or provide advice about specific investments.

Each advisor listed on our site is an independent fiduciary responsible for their own advice. Warmer may receive fees from advisors for participation or referrals; these fees are paid by advisors and do not affect the fees clients pay for advisory services.

For advisor listings, we rely on sources including public filings and data provided by advisors, and we cannot guarantee that all information is current or accurate. Please review an advisor's Form ADV and do your own diligence before entering into an advisory relationship.

By using our service, you agree to Warmer's Terms of Service and Advisory Agreement and Privacy Policy. Logos provided by Logo.dev

© 2026 Warmer Holdings Inc. ("Warmer")