user avatar

Susan Metcalf

Advisor at Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.

Updated today

Location

Sweet, ID

Credentials

CFA®, Series 63, Series 65

Industry experience

39 years

About

Susan Metcalf is a CFA® charterholder with 39 years of industry experience. She is currently with Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc., where she has worked since 2017, and has also been with Sutter Securities Inc. since 2010. Outside of her advisory role, she serves as Vice President of Letha Irrigation and Water Company, which manages water rights for agricultural land, and is a managing partner of a family partnership that owns ranch property. Caldwell Sutter Capital primarily serves high-net-worth individuals, families, and related entities, along with corporate and municipal clients. The firm employs a bottom-up, fundamental value investment approach with a long-term, buy-and-hold orientation, managing roughly $606 million across customized portfolio strategies.

Client services

Based on Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.

Financial planning Portfolio management

Expertise

Based on Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.

Retirement income strategy Charitable giving & philanthropy Gifting strategies Business exit / sale strategy Tax-loss harvesting

Occupation focus

Based on Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.

Founder/Business Owner Executive

Not sure if this advisor is right for you?

Answer a few questions to see advisors matched to you.

Fee options

Percentage

$0+: 0.5% annually on fixed income securities (Treasuries, corporate bonds, municipal bonds, government securities) $0+: 0.5% annually on limited partnerships and other private funds managed by third parties $0+: 1.0% annually on ETFs and closed-end funds included in CS Value Equity $0+: 1.5% annually on individually researched equities in CS Value Equity 0+: 0.15% to 1.5% annually flat fee range for CS Strategic Diversified (negotiated based on asset size and complexity)

Commissions

Commission-based compensation earned by registered representatives in their separate capacities when purchasing or selling securities or insurance products; separate and in addition to advisory fees.

Other

Account minimum: $250,000

Location

Sweet, ID

Most active in

Idaho

Work history

Caldwell Securities, Inc.

2017 - Present (9 years)

Sutter Securities Inc.

2010 - Present (16 years)

Disclosures

Exclamation point means they have disclosures of this type. Check mark means no disclosures of this type were found.

Business activities & affiliations

user avatar

Aaron F

Series 65

Horseshoe Bend, ID

Sage Mountain Wealth Management

Aaron Flores is a financial advisor at Sage Mountain Wealth Management in Horseshoe Bend, ID, holding a Series 65 designation with three years of industry experience. He has been involved with My Day Counts since 2013. Sage Mountain Wealth Management provides investment management and financial planning to individuals, high-net-worth clients, small businesses, retirement plans, and private foundations. The firm employs a globally diversified, long-term asset allocation approach using fundamental and quantitative analysis, offering customized portfolios that often include index funds, ETFs, individual equities, and select alternative investments.

General retirement planning Retirement income strategy Passive / index investing Private / alternative investments
user avatar

Renee F

Series 63, Series 65

Ketchum, ID

American Capital Advisory, LLC

Renee Faltings is a financial advisor at American Capital Advisory, LLC with 23 years of industry experience. She holds Series 63 and Series 65 designations and has worked previously at Clearrock Capital, LLC. Outside of her advisory role, she is involved in retail sales through PK's Sports. American Capital Advisory provides discretionary investment management to individuals, high-net-worth clients, corporations, trusts, estates, charitable organizations, and financial institutions. The firm employs a global asset allocation strategy primarily using low-cost ETFs and mutual funds, supplemented by tax-sensitive direct indexing and a range of trading tools tailored to client objectives.

Passive / index investing Active portfolio management Tax-loss harvesting Options & derivatives strategies
user avatar

Matthew C

CFA®, Series 63

Richmond, VA

American Capital Advisory, LLC

Matthew Cullen is a CFA® charterholder and Series 63 licensee with one year of experience in the financial industry. He has worked at American Capital Advisory, LLC since 2021 and previously spent 14 years at Thompson, Siegel & Walmsley. American Capital Advisory, LLC manages approximately $255 million for around 348 clients, including individuals, high-net-worth clients, corporations, and charitable organizations. The firm employs a global asset allocation strategy using low-cost ETFs and mutual funds, supplemented by tax-sensitive direct indexing and a broader trading toolkit tailored to client objectives.

Passive / index investing Active portfolio management Tax-loss harvesting Options & derivatives strategies
user avatar

Ian J

Series 65

Ketchum, ID

American Capital Advisory, LLC

Ian Jameson is a financial advisor with American Capital Advisory, LLC in Ketchum, ID, holding a Series 65 designation and 17 years of industry experience. He has been with American Capital Advisory since 2012. Outside of his advisory role, he serves as board chair of Idaho's Bounty Cooperative, a food cooperative where he is involved in strategy, finance, and nonprofit relationships. American Capital Advisory provides discretionary investment management to individuals, high-net-worth clients, corporations, trusts, estates, charitable organizations, and financial institutions. The firm manages approximately $255 million for around 348 clients through a team of seven advisors, employing a global asset allocation approach with low-cost ETFs, mutual funds, and tax-sensitive direct indexing, supplemented by a range of trading strategies tailored to client objectives.

Passive / index investing Active portfolio management Tax-loss harvesting Options & derivatives strategies
user avatar

Matthew M

CFA®, Series 65

Ketchum, ID

American Capital Advisory, LLC

Matthew Mcneal is a CFA® charterholder with 16 years of industry experience, currently serving at American Capital Advisory, LLC since 2012. He holds a Series 65 license and is based in Ketchum, Idaho. Outside of his advisory role, Mcneal is a board director at Argent Development Corp. of Virginia and participates in private restaurant investment through DS Group, LLC. American Capital Advisory provides discretionary investment management to individuals, high-net-worth clients, corporations, trusts, estates, charitable organizations, and financial institutions. The firm manages approximately $255 million for around 348 clients using a global asset allocation approach primarily implemented with low-cost ETFs and mutual funds, supplemented by tax-sensitive direct indexing and a broader trading toolkit tailored to client objectives.

Passive / index investing Active portfolio management Tax-loss harvesting Options & derivatives strategies
user avatar

Maunsel H

Series 66

Ketchum, ID

American Capital Advisory, LLC

Maunsel Hickey is a financial advisor at American Capital Advisory, LLC with 19 years of industry experience. He holds a Series 66 designation and has worked at firms including Mercer Global Advisors, ClearRock Capital, Seaport Global Securities, and BB&T Securities. American Capital Advisory is a team of seven advisors managing approximately $255 million for individuals, high-net-worth clients, corporations, trusts, estates, charitable organizations, and financial institutions. The firm focuses on global asset allocation using low-cost ETFs and mutual funds, tax-sensitive direct indexing, and employs a broader trading toolkit including short sales and option writing tailored to client objectives.

Passive / index investing Active portfolio management Tax-loss harvesting Options & derivatives strategies
Warmer team member

Not sure where to start?

We'll help you think it through — whether you ultimately need an advisor or not.

Warmer helps you compare advisors clearly — so you can choose with confidence.

Find your advisor
Discover

Compare top advisor firms by metric, firm size, and location.

Warmer provides personalized recommendations and introductions to independent fiduciary advisors. We do not supervise advisors, manage or hold assets, guarantee performance, or provide advice about specific investments.

Each advisor listed on our site is an independent fiduciary responsible for their own advice. Warmer may receive fees from advisors for participation or referrals; these fees are paid by advisors and do not affect the fees clients pay for advisory services.

For advisor listings, we rely on sources including public filings and data provided by advisors, and we cannot guarantee that all information is current or accurate. Please review an advisor's Form ADV and do your own diligence before entering into an advisory relationship.

By using our service, you agree to Warmer's Terms of Service and Advisory Agreement and Privacy Policy. Logos provided by Logo.dev

© 2026 Warmer Holdings Inc. ("Warmer")